The List
Search and find Chicagoland events
From: to:
Time Out Stories
Ideas on how to fix the pension crisis
By Robert McCoppin | Daily Herald Staff - 4/28/2010
Civic watchdogs, unions, taxpayers groups and lawmakers propose several ways to deal with the state's $78 billion debt to public pension systems: BACK TO STORY

Reader Comments

1. Comments are not edited and don't represent the views of Daily Herald
2. To understand what is and isn't allowed please read our comments policy
3. To report an inappropriate post click the icon beneath the comment

Place a comment

You have 1200 characters left.

You must be signed in to participate in commenting

Already a member? Sign in:

Remember my sign in

Not a member?

Go to our member services section and join DailyHerald.com.

Sign up now
You have not completed the sign-up process.
Please check your e-mail for instructions
on how to activate your account.

Story text

Civic watchdogs, unions, taxpayers groups and lawmakers propose several ways to deal with the state's $78 billion debt to public pension systems:

Illinois General Assembly

Reform measure signed April 14 by Gov. Pat Quinn.

Key point: Changes apply only to people not yet hired.

Pro: Lowers future costs by more than $200 billion over decades.

Con: Doesn't touch state's $78 billion debt to the pension system.

• Raises minimum retirement age for teachers, state and university employees, judges and lawmakers from 55 to 67.

• Calculates pension only up to $106,800 of salary.

• Lowers pension percentage for new judges and lawmakers from 85 percent to 60 percent of salary.

• Generally limits pension cost-of-living increases to half of the Consumer Price Index or 3 percent, whichever is lower.

Civic Committee of the Commercial Club of Chicago

Civic business group

Key point: Would limit benefits tied to future earnings of current employees. No changes for current retirees' benefits.

Pro: Would save an estimated $2 billion a year immediately.

Con: Reduced benefits might keep top employees out of public service, unions say.

• Increase employee contributions by at least 1 percentage point (public school teachers and administrators now pay 9.4 percent.)

• Require retirees to pay more for health care.

• Better yet, replace pensions with a defined contribution plan such as 401(k).

Center for Tax and Budget Accountability

Board includes unions and social advocacy groups.

Key point: Depends on new revenue, not benefit reductions.

Pro: Quickest to pay off state's pension obligation and reduce interest payments.

Con: Would raise taxes significantly.

• Tax services such as dry cleaning and auto repair to raise state revenue.

• Require the state to pay its full pension obligation each year.

• Change the Illinois Constitution to create a progressive income tax, with a higher tax rate for higher incomes.

Illinois Policy Institute

Supports "free market" policy

Key point: Borrow money and rein in spending to pay the pension debt.

Pro: Ultimately designed to balance budget.

Con: Borrowing would merely delay day of reckoning, conservative critics say.

• Borrow $18 billion over the next 15 years to make required annual payments to pension fund.

• Freeze state budget for three years at 2010 levels.

• Limit future state budget increases to inflation rate plus population increase.

• Use projected excess revenue to pay down the pension debt and then pay tax refunds.

• Sell or lease state assets like the tollways.

National Taxpayers United

Conservative taxpayers group

Key point: Would abolish state pensions.

Pro: Would save an estimated $50 billion in coming decades.

Con: Reduces benefits far below other public-sector workers'.

• End pensions for new state hires and replace it with Social Security, Medicare and 401(k) contributions.

• Require current workers to contribute 8 percent more of their income toward pension and health benefits and $250 per month after retirement.

Sources: Illinois General Assembly, Civic Committee, Center for Tax and Budget Accountability, Illinois Policy Institute, National Taxpayers United of Illinois.

See all